ESL Forum:
Techniques and methods
in Language Teaching
Games, activities
and teaching ideas
Grammar and
Linguistics
Teaching material
Concerning
worksheets
Concerning
powerpoints
Concerning online
exercises
Make suggestions,
report errors
Ask for help
Message board
|
ESL forum >
Message board > What does this sentence express?
What does this sentence express?
Nizarsouth
|
What does this sentence express?
|
Hi colleagues! in the text book of my students I have this question: What does this sentence express? "I do sometimes wonder what it would
be like if she were like me And we
could go clubbing together" as far as I know it �s a conditional sentence type two: if+simple past=would + infinitive. My students might ask me why " she were" and not "she was". I �m thinking of saying to them that it �s an unreal present to express an event that didn �t happen. Is it a Satisfactory
explanation? Is there any other explanation or answer? Thanks a lot for your help.
|
12 Nov 2010
|
|
|
aliciapc
|
I just tell teach them that with "if" and "I wish" or "if only", in those three cases we use "were" with all the personal pronouns. Just that. |
12 Nov 2010
|
|
Mukkik
|
Using "she were" instead of "was" shows that it is really impossible, we insist on the fact that it is hypothetical. |
12 Nov 2010
|
|
libertybelle
|
It is a subjunctive verb. There are not many left - but it has to do with verbs having moods! a kinds of conditional wishful thinking:
You can read more about subjunctive verbs below:
http://grammar.quickanddirtytips.com/subjunctive-verbs-was-i-were.aspx
another site says the following:
- Subjunctives.
Anyone
who �s studied a foreign language will be glad that English has
almost entirely lost the subjunctives it once had. And because
English has so few inflections,
it �s often hard to spot many subjunctives. Grammarians have a
hard time defining subjunctive; don �t worry if you don �t
follow.
Unlike the indicative mood,
which indicates that something is true, the
subjunctive expresses a wish, a command, or a condition
contrary to fact. Archaic English is full of subjunctives, as in
"Would that it were" and "Thou shalt not."
The English subjunctive still shows up in a few places, of
which the condition contrary to fact is most common:
- Conditions contrary to fact: "If I were a rich
man." (I teach English; Lord knows I ain �t rich.) We use
were instead of the expected is, am, or
are: "If this were any heavier [but it �s not
� a condition contrary to fact], I couldn �t lift it"; "If
she were to say that [but she �s not], I �d leave."
- Suppositions: "If I were to tell you, I �d have
to kill you"; "Be that as it may."
- Wishes: "I wish I had an Illudium PU-36
Explosive Space Modulator"; "I wish she were six inches
taller."
- Demands and suggestions: "I insisted that he
leave"; "I suggested he leave."
- Necessity or importance: "It �s essential that he
arrive on time."
|
12 Nov 2010
|
|
mourad1O
|
Hi, Actually your question has one exact answer: It is conditional type II= expressing wishes in the present. It expresses unreal fact in the present using the past form of the verbs. The past is used to show that she can never be me. It is just supposition. Both "were or "was" are used without any difference in meaning.
You can �t say it talks about something that didn �t happen (but that can �t be true: or imaginary)). Be careful, the sentence (meaning) is in the present though the form is in the past.
Good luck
|
12 Nov 2010
|
|
|
|