ESL Forum:
Techniques and methods
in Language Teaching
Games, activities
and teaching ideas
Grammar and
Linguistics
Teaching material
Concerning
worksheets
Concerning
powerpoints
Concerning online
exercises
Make suggestions,
report errors
Ask for help
Message board
|
ESL forum >
Ask for help > Breakfast, Dinner, Tea
Breakfast, Dinner, Tea
spinney
|
Breakfast, Dinner, Tea
|
Hi People!
I �ve been at a summer camp for a week or two and I �m going back this weekend. This year we are using English speaking volunteers as conversation assistants and monitors. These volunteers have never taught English and we use them to get the students to get accustomed to speaking to natives. The kids are very confused by a lot of what they hear. One of the things they find most confusing is this thing we have in the British Isles about calling lunch "dinner" and dinner "tea." Where I come from we say it this way. Most people I know from the North say it this way and I know a few Londoners that employ it, too. And the women that used to supervise children �s lunch time in the UK were called "dinner ladies." Not "lunch ladies." Is this a class thing or a regional thing? What do you call it where you come from? Are there other English speaking parts of the world where this happens? Is just that I �m thinking of creating some kind of activity about this. |
11 Jul 2012
|
|
|
English-Castle
|
The origins of the word dinner means meal, but it must be more confusing to use the word tea for a meal in the evening rather than a good cup of rosy lee but maybe I am just tiffing! |
11 Jul 2012
|
|
cunliffe
|
Where I come from they have breakfast, dinner, tea and supper. It is mainly regional, but I think there is a class thing as well. We always thought it was very posh if anyone talked about lunch!
Now I always have lunch and I have dinner in the evening. I also have patio doors (not to eat!). Boy, am I middle class! |
11 Jul 2012
|
|
|
moravc
|
This is what I was taught - dinner = the main meal of the day, supper = small meal / salad, tea = snack in the afternoon
breakfast in the morning
lunch at 12-14 - could be a sandwich, salad, soup, or a small cooked meal
tea - a light snack + drink at 16-17
dinner - a big meal, the main meal of the day - at 12-14 or 18-20, at the dinner table, with friends, with candles, "special occasion"
supper - a small meal, "light" supper, cooked meal or a salad, smaller portions, could be served later in the evening (20,00)
So in some cases dinner = lunch = supper -> Dinner might be lunch or supper, accoring to the portions and time of the day when served
|
11 Jul 2012
|
|
moravc
|
See wikipedia http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dinner http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Supper
Supper may refer to, on largely class-based distinctions, either a
late-evening snack (working and middle class usage) or to make a
distinction between "supper" as an informal family meal (which would be
eaten in the kitchen or family dining room) as opposed to "dinner";
generally a grander affair (either or both in terms of the meal and the
courses within the meal itself), which would be eaten in the best dining
room, may well have guests from outside the household, and for which
there may be a dress code.
It is common for social interest and hobby clubs that meet in the
evening after normal dinner hours to announce that "a light supper" will
be served after the main business of the meeting.
In England, whereas "dinner", when used for the evening meal, is
fairly formal, "supper" is used to describe a less formal, simpler
family meal. In some areas of the United Kingdom, "supper" is used to
describe an evening meal when dinner has been eaten around noon. In some northern British and Australian homes, as in New Zealand and Ireland, "tea"
is used for the evening meal. In parts of the United Kingdom, supper is
a term for a snack eaten lafter the evening meal and before bed, usually
consisting of a warm, milky drink and British biscuits or cereal, but can include sandwiches.
In Ireland, a "chicken supper" is a meal of chips, gravy, onions,
peas and chicken breast. Similarly in Scotland and perhaps elsewhere in
the United Kingdom, such as in Ulster Scots, a fish supper is a portion of fish and chips. The word is used also as a modifier in this way for a range of other similar meals, such as a "sausage supper", "pastie supper", "haggis supper" and indicates the presence of chips.
In New Zealand it is similar � generally cake and tea/coffee served
later in the evening, particularly when people have visitors.
The distinction between dinner and supper was common in United States
farming communities into the twentieth century. In most parts of The
United States and Canada today, "supper" and "dinner" are considered
synonyms. In many areas, including Ontario, the term "supper" may be rarely used. In Saskatchewan, and much of Atlantic Canada,
"supper" means the main meal of the day, usually served in the late
afternoon, while "dinner" is served around noon. "Dinner" is used in
some areas, such as Newfoundland and Labrador,
to describe the noon meal as well as special meals, such as
"Thanksgiving Dinner" or "Christmas Dinner", the evening meal being
"supper". For harvest meals put on by churches and other community
organizations, the term used is "Fowl Supper" (features turkey) or "Fall
Supper", never "dinner".
On the Philippines, dinner, in contrast with supper, is taken well
past noon (4 pm-7 pm), hence termed "Hapunan" from "hapon" meaning
"noon", it is usually the formal-heavy meal, while supper is usually
taken night-time (8 pm-10 pm), likewise termed "Gabihan" from "gabi"
meaning "evening or night", is usually a casual-light meal, before
sleeping. In Malaysia and Singapore, "dinner" refers to the first
evening meal, while "supper" refers to the meal taken later in the
evening after dinner, usually between 9PM and midnight.
|
11 Jul 2012
|
|
moravc
|
As you can see, it is complicated...
But the standard way is: dinner = the main meal of the day (either at noon or in the eveing)
supper = light meal of the day (sandwich, salad, or soup)
tea = biscuits + drink = "snack"
In literature or films the usage of supper, dinner and tea as well as slang expressions often indicate the class of the main character or his/her "origin" - hometown / homecountry. Watch and read Jane Austen books - films or contemporary films with your students... It varies...
|
11 Jul 2012
|
|
yanogator
|
There was an episode of the British SitCom "Are You Being Served" (I think that �s from the 1970s) in which the very proper Captain Peacock reprimanded the rather low-class Miss Brahms for talking about Breakfast, Dinner and Supper. He told her in no uncertain terms that educated people eat Breakfast, Lunch and Dinner. Tea didn �t enter into the conversation.
Bruce |
11 Jul 2012
|
|
PhilipR
|
Let �s just say that in world English the following goes (no matter how big or important the meal in question is):
Morning meal: breakfast Midday meal: lunch Evening meal: dinner
I agree there are many regional differences, but unless someone is preparing for overseas travel to a particular country, I don �t see the point in explaining these regional idiosyncrasies. |
11 Jul 2012
|
|
|
douglas
|
Moravc �s first post is pretty-much spot-on and I agree with Philip about breakfast, lunch, dinner being "world English".
However, I think (as a minimum) the concept of "tea-time" ( I was taught that it was more of a late afternoon snack of maybe tea and cookies) should be taught. I also suggest that you explain "Sunday dinner" (the big family meal usually eaten in the early afternoon--after church-- on Sundays).
Cheers,
Douglas |
12 Jul 2012
|
|
1
2
Next >
|