Welcome to
ESL Printables, the website where English Language teachers exchange resources: worksheets, lesson plans,  activities, etc.
Our collection is growing every day with the help of many teachers. If you want to download you have to send your own contributions.

 


 

 

 

ESL Forum:

Techniques and methods in Language Teaching

Games, activities and teaching ideas

Grammar and Linguistics

Teaching material

Concerning worksheets

Concerning powerpoints

Concerning online exercises

Make suggestions, report errors

Ask for help

Message board

 

ESL forum > Grammar and Linguistics > Use of comparatives and superlative.    

Use of comparatives and superlative.



goodnesses
Algeria

Use of comparatives and superlative.
 
Hi, All!
I have a doubt and I would like to have your help.
These are examples taken from an excellent WS uploaded today.

Turkey is larger than Japan but

Japan has higher population than Turkey.

 

Brazil is smaller than Canada but

Canada is less populated than Brazil.

 

Canada is the largest country but

Brazil is the most populated of all.

The comparative adj. in the second example bugs me a little.
When we say that A is larger than B, we infer that both A and B are large.
So can we say than B is smaller than A?
If yes my question will be are A and B large or small?

Wouldn �t it be apropriate to say that B isn �t as large as A?

23 Mar 2009      





Zora
Canada

I have to agree with Silke, Goodnesses...and it also sounds quite fine to my "native speaker" ears! LOL Maybe you are just having an off day... Smile

23 Mar 2009     



goodnesses
Algeria

Hi, Zora.
I am not having an day off . It is Spring holidays here.

I just want to understand.

So, are they large or small?
Because I can �t see how they can be both.
Try to put aside everyday or spoken language.


I am not complicating at all Silke. I don �t want to teach my PP something which would sound illogical.

23 Mar 2009     



goodnesses
Algeria

When we deal with the degree of difference we use "much" or "a bit" or "a little" or "far more"...

23 Mar 2009     



Zora
Canada

Think of a house with rooms that are more or less the same size:

The main bathroom is as big as the den but smaller than the living room. Although, it is bigger than the ironing room on the second floor which isn �t as big as the kitchen on the first which is larger than my bedroom...

Confused yet??? LOL

23 Mar 2009     



maker1
Turkey

What I meant to say was this:
 
Brazil is smaller than Canada (areawise)
Canada is less populated than Brazil.(which is self explanatory)
OR
Canada is larger than Brasil but
its population is smaller than Brasil

23 Mar 2009     



goodnesses
Algeria

Yes still.

So if we say that "An elephant is heavier than a mouse." no one would understand that a mouse is heavy.

23 Mar 2009     



goodnesses
Algeria

It is the same Maker1.

We can �t use one ADJ and its opposite to describe the same thing.

Barzil and Canada cannot be large and small in the same time (area or population).

23 Mar 2009     



goodnesses
Algeria

No Silke I would say: An elephant is very heavy whereas a mouse is very light.

23 Mar 2009     



eng789
Israel

It all depends on what you are trying to say. 
 
You choose the adjective you want to use.
 
as big as   or     as small as  -   you need to decide what you want to relate to - big or small
 
 
 

23 Mar 2009     



maker1
Turkey

No I did not take it the wrong way and that is why I have removed my post

23 Mar 2009     

1    2    3    Next >